Must Have Baby Registry Items to Put On Your List
Preparing for a new baby can feel overwhelming, especially when it comes to creating a baby registry. This article will guide you through the best baby registry items to include on your list, ensuring you have everything you need for your little one’s arrival. From essential nursery gear to practical everyday items, we’ll cover what will truly make a difference in your journey as a new parent. Are you ready? Let’s get started!
What to Put On Your Baby Registry
Your baby registry should include essentials like a sturdy stroller, wipes, and diapers, but it should also include thoughtful baby gifts that help your baby stand out with a charming style. These are the things we want to show you. Below, you’ll find some of our favorite baby toys, blankets, onesies, and more.
1. Organic NYC Print Baby Romper Onesie
Add a touch of NYC charm to your baby registry with our organic cotton "BIG CITY" romper. Featuring cute prints of iconic symbols like taxis, pretzels, and pizza, this soft and stylish romper is perfect for any nursery. It makes an excellent gift for new parents or a delightful outfit for your little one. Don't miss out on this must-have NYC-themed piece!
Why Parents Love It
Love the NYC theme: This romper is a perfect gift for any NYC lover! The print is adorable, and the quality is outstanding. The fabric feels so soft and is ideal for babies with sensitive skin. I’m so happy I found this!
Katie B
The cutest outfit ever: I can’t say enough good things about this romper. It’s not only stylish with its fun NYC print, but it’s also super comfortable for my baby. The material is light and breathable. We’ve gotten so many compliments on this outfit!
Sara J.
2. Brooklyn Buddies Onesie
Welcome your little one to the vibrant spirit of Brooklyn with our Brooklyn Buddies organic baby onesie. Perfect as a baby shower gift and featuring playful hotdog and pretzel characters crossing the iconic Brooklyn Bridge, this soft onesie is a delightful way to show off your baby's borough pride. It’s not just an outfit; it’s a fun, comfy choice for any baby registry.
Why Parents Love It
Absolutely precious!: I have a future granddaughter arriving near the end of November, and she will be welcomed into a diversity-embracing home! This precious little bodysuit makes that statement without being so “in your face”.
Lynn S
Beautiful soft clothing: Bought this baby grow as a gift for my friends 1yr old. Beautiful soft fabric and design and it arrived very quickly! Would highly recommend and will definitely be ordering from Estella again :)
Miriam A
3. Bicycle Baby Onesie
Set your baby on a path to sustainability with our organic cotton bicycle embroidered onesie. Crafted from the softest striped cotton, this fun outfit celebrates the joy of biking—the fastest and greenest way to navigate the city. There’s nothing quite like the thrill of handlebar streamers fluttering in the breeze! Don’t forget to add this adorable piece to your baby registry clothing checklist!
Why Parents Love It
ADORABLE!! I purchased the taxi embroidered bodysuit as a gift to my daughter, who is giving me my first grandchild arriving in June. My daughter is a NYC transplant now living in Austin but missing everything about the city she loved. She specifically asked me to buy this & was thrilled when it arrived."
Anonymous
4. Cotton Baby Blankets - Heart Large
Baby blankets are an amazing gift, even for your second baby registry (and more posibly after that). Our beloved heart baby blankets are back, now crafted from the softest Peruvian organic cotton. Measuring about 30 inches square, these timeless blankets are both practical and beautiful, making them ideal for all seasons.
Why Parents Love It
Adorable blanket: I bought this blanket for my daughter and son-in-law who spent many years in NYC and are expecting a child. They loved it!
Anonymous
Related: First Birthday Gift Ideas
5. Organic Baby Lovey Blanket - Large Taxi
Check out our large taxi-themed blanket featuring bold stripes and a delightful design. It’s perfect for snuggling or nursery decor. Complete the look with our hand-knit striped hats made from ultra-soft organic cotton, suitable for infants up to six months. Add these essentials to your baby registry today!
Why Parents Love It
Perfect keepsake: Ever since I received a gift from Estella at my own shower, this has been my go-to place! I love how special each piece feels. These are the perfect gifts for NYC babies. Definitely keepsakes.
Shelley
Meaningful gift: NYC has always held a special place in my family’s heart, so it is just fitting to purchase this for my soon-to-come grandchild!
Melanie
6. Organic Striped Baby Hats, Handmade
Baby hats are often a forgotten baby registry item. Include these adorable hats on your little one's head with our striped knit hats, made from the softest non-itch organic cotton. These hats are perfect for infants up to six months old and are hand-crafted in Peru. They make a lovely addition to any baby gift set.
Why Parents Love It
Baby hat: My future granddaughter will look very cute in her well-made, warm hat! I'm glad that I could support a small business.( P.S. I am a native New Yorker) Thank you :-)
Anonymous
Hat: Hello, the quality of your baby clothing is supreme. I am so glad I found you. My first grandson will be arriving in March and we will be a regular on your site.... love it!!!!
Bonnie S.
7. Flash Knit Doll, Handmade
Introduce your little one to Flash, an adorable and quirky soft baby doll from Estella's collection of knit toddler toys. He's ready to be your child's new companion, eager for fun and imaginative play. Add this charming doll to your baby registry for a delightful and unique gift!
Why Parents Love It
The design is not only cute but also sparks the imagination. My son loves to create stories around his Flash Doll, making it a great tool for creative play. It’s wonderful to see him so engaged!
Samantha R
As a parent, I feel good about giving my child a toy that’s made from organic cotton. It’s safe, soft, and easy to wash, which is essential for little ones who love to explore everything with their mouths.
Michelle T
8. Organic Knit Doll, Franny Flamingo
Franny is handcrafted from the softest organic cotton, this glamorous 12" tall doll loves to be in the spotlight. Franny makes a delightful present for anyone who appreciates a bit of flair. Don’t forget to add this whimsical doll to your baby registry!
Why Parents Love It
Très Charmant: This sweet little bird is adorable, and I love the texture. My first grandchild will be born soon, and I can't wait to give this to her. Her parents love that it's non-toxic and baby-safe. This is a perfect little gift!
Belinda
Well-made and cute!: This Franny Flamingo knit doll has become a favorite in our family with multiple kids fighting over it. Such a cute and high-quality toy.
PCR
9. Cactus Newborn Rattles
Add some charm to your baby registry with our delightful cactus baby rattle, made from ultra-soft organic cotton and handcrafted in Peru. With its friendly face and gentle rattle, this toy is perfect for nature-loving families!
Why Parents Love It
Sooo cute, it’s the right size for little hands, very soft, my grandson is due in 2 weeks and it’s a perfect Christmas gift."
B Weber
Great little rattle, soft, perfect for my new grandson!
Tammy V
10. Lion Rattle Toy
Estella's lion rattle is a classic choice for baby gifts, crafted from certified organic cotton; safe for newborns, it’s a thoughtful gift to a baby registry for a perfect blend of fun and safety.
Why Parents Love It
Perfect gift for my grandson. It’s made of organic cotton, which is a huge plus. The lion is soft and easy for little hands to hold. He’s been carrying it everywhere!”
Sandra P.
I bought this for my niece’s baby, and they loved it! The lion’s mane and vibrant color make it super appealing for the baby to play with. The rattle sound isn’t too loud, which is great for soothing her.
Mara L
11. Sparky the Dog Stuffed Animal Toy
For dog enthusiasts, Sparky the Dog is a cuddly, hypoallergenic stuffed animal that makes an ideal companion for snuggling. This charming toy combines safety with an adorable design, making it a perfect addition to any baby registry.
Why Parents Love It
Sparky became my son’s favorite instantly! The soft knit and the adorable sweater design make it easy for him to carry everywhere. It’s well-made, and I love that it's organic cotton."
Melissa J
Perfect addition to our toy collection! My daughter loves playing with Sparky, and I appreciate the quality of the materials used. It’s been washed a few times and still looks brand new!
Hannah R
12. Chicago Baby Gift Set
Take a tiny tour of Chicago with our charming Windy City baby gift set. This six-piece bundle captures the magic of raising little ones in the heart of the Midwest, featuring organic cotton rattles inspired by Chicago landmarks, from Sue the T-Rex to the beloved Lakefront Trail. The set includes four hand-crafted rattles, a beautifully embroidered organic cotton onesie, and the delightful "Chicago ABCs" board book by Mr. Boddington – everything a budding Chicagoan needs to fall in love with their hometown.
Why Parents Love It
The perfect gift! Purchased the Chicago Baby Gift Set for a friend and it was a hit. The items were well-made and well-received. Great for a Chicago baby and super cute. Very happy with my purchase
13. 'Sparkie' Dog Baby Gift Set with Onesie & Bib
For the dog lovers in your life, this whimsical baby set is pure puppy perfection. The playful onesie and matching kerchief bib feature an all-over print of frisky pups living their best lives – from determined Beagles chasing pigeons to mischievous French Bulldogs stealing baguettes. Each scene tells its own tiny story across the soft cotton fabric, making this set an irresistible gift for any family that cherishes their four-legged friends.
Why Parents Love It
Great Baby Shower Gift: I purchased the dog-themed onesie and bib set for a friend’s baby shower, and she loved it! The material is incredibly soft, and the design is both adorable and unique. I appreciate that it’s made from organic cotton, and the little dogs on the print are a fun touch. The quality is excellent—after a few washes, it still looks brand new. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a special baby gift!
Lauren S.
14. Muslin NYC Baby Swaddle
Experience the Big Apple from day one with Loulou Lollipop's charming NYC muslin swaddle. This generously sized 47"x 47" blanket wraps your little New Yorker in scenes of city magic, from the towering Empire State Building to Lady Liberty herself. Playfully scattered among these landmarks, you'll spot beloved city symbols – yellow taxis, street-cart pretzels, hot dogs, and the classic NYC apple – creating the perfect blend of comfort and hometown pride.
Why Parents Love It
Estella customer for life!
Originally received an Estella gift box for my baby shower and was blown away by the adorable and unique NYC themed pieces. A few months later, I decided to gift some items to a friend who is expecting (she loved it also!) and I saw the swaddle. I had to have it. The price point is comparable to other popular name brands for the same item but the unique NYC theme and use of soft colors makes it a winner. I’ll be an Estella customer for life!
15. Organic Baby Sleeveless Romper - Apple
Meet the sweetest baby essential: our organic cotton romper featuring a charming red apple design. Hand-knit in soft cream with a bold apple motif, this modern heirloom piece makes an unforgettable baby shower gift. Best of all? Despite its boutique look, this standout romper is refreshingly practical – just toss it in the washing machine and it's ready for baby's next adventure.
Why Parents Love It
Perpetual gift I buy this brand for everyone, they all love it"
16. Striped Puppy Love Organic Romper
Meet our Puppy Love Organic Romper, where playful pups meet classic stripes! On a fresh French blue striped background, an enthusiastic Lab chases their beloved ball while a charming Bulldog joins the fun. Crafted from the softest organic cotton, this romper isn't just adorable – it's practical too, with convenient snap closures at the shoulders and legs for fuss-free diaper changes. It's the perfect blend of whimsy and everyday comfort for your little dog lover.
Why Parents Love It
So soft and adorable: Adorable, super soft and breathable, what more could you ask for! Our little guys on the long side so we went a few sizes bigger just to be safe (and get a lot of wear out of it) Item is so cute and exactly as pictured. Highly recommend the small company. Customer service is excellent as well.
17. Ladybug Stuffed Animal
Our charming ladybug stuffed animal has the phrase "love bug" beautifully embroidered on its belly. It makes a lovely gift for a baby registry, a perfect blend of charm and meaning!
Why Parents Love It
The ladybug is not only super cute but also feels incredibly soft and high-quality. I appreciate the attention to detail, from the stitching to the materials used. Knowing it’s organic gives me peace of mind as my little one plays with it constantly.
Carmen A
This is by far the most adorable stuffed animal I’ve ever seen. The craftsmanship is just beautiful, and I love that it’s organic and safe for my baby. My daughter hasn’t let it go since I gave it to her. It’s now her favorite snuggle buddy at night, and it’s the perfect size for her tiny hands to hold!
Jacqueline L
Find Your Baby Registry Items With Estella Today!
Building your baby registry can feel overwhelming, but starting with these essential items - soft, breathable baby onesies for everyday wear, cozy blankets for swaddling and comfort, practical bibs to keep mealtime manageable, and snug hats to regulate your little one's temperature - will set a strong foundation for your baby's needs. We also have a guide on how many items to put on your baby registry. This will help you create the perfect list that works for both you and your generous gift-givers.
