The 28 Best Baby Shower Gifts According to New Parents

Going to a baby shower? Don’t worry, we’ve got you covered. Here at Estella, we’ve curated a special list of the best gifts you can bring to a friend or family’s baby shower. Not only are the gifts organic and made with extra TLC, but they’re also sure to be a hit for the newborn. Let’s get started! Short on time? Browse all of our baby shower gifts.

1. Large NYC Taxi Plush

A soft, squeezable plush taxi that’s one of our most popular baby gifts among new parents. It’s big enough to hug, sweet enough to leave out as nursery decor, and a playful way to give a new baby a little piece of New York. A thoughtful gift for baby boys and girls alike.

Why Parents Love It

Organic Stuffed Taxi Cab Pillow: We received our soft Taxi Cab Pillow from Estella - and it is everything we wanted in this item - soft, cute and cuddly.

Anonymous

2. Organic Giraffe Baby Newborn Rattle

Parents rave about this giraffe rattle, a charming and sensory-engaging toy for newborns. Hand-knit in Peru with an organic cotton exterior, its long neck and legs, along with the gentle rattle, make it easy for babies to hold and shake. Its spotted design adds a playful touch, making it an ideal addition to any baby shower gift. Perfect for any baby registry.

Why Parents Love It

Parents love our giraffe rattle because it is beautifully made:

Adorable: Great! Perfectly made and cute as can be ❤️

Suzette B.

3. Baby New Yorker Gift Set

This Baby New Yorker gift set is a must-have for city-loving parents. It includes a taxi-printed organic cotton onesie, a matching NYC bib, a muslin swaddle, and a pacifier holder. Also included are Frank the NYC dog doll, a taxi bear soother, a NYC-themed board book, and two award-winning rattles. This set is perfect for newborns and will be cherished for years to come.

Why Parents Love It

My Go-To Baby Gift Now: This officially became my go-to baby gift for NYC families. Thoughtful, adorable, and consistently well received.

4. A Great Onesie Body Suit

These organic onesie bodysuits are a staple in any baby’s wardrobe. Made from soft organic cotton, they’re ideal for everyday wear. They make a practical and thoughtful gift that every parent will appreciate.

Why Parents Love It

Too Cute!! Obsessed-great color and quality stitching

Meghan M

Baby Gift for a friend. She loves it! I bought a friend two Ladybug bodysuits as a gift. She loves them both! Very soft material, well made and the baby looks so cute! Highly recommend!

S.

5. Muslin NYC Baby Swaddle

Did you know swaddles are a commonly forgotten baby registry item? Wrap your little one in the heart of NYC with Loulou Lollipop's Muslin Swaddle! Perfect for parents and baby shower gifting, this stylish swaddle features beloved landmarks like the Statue of Liberty, Empire State Building, and Washington Square Arch, along with iconic NYC symbols like the apple, pretzel, taxi, and hot dog.

Why Parents Love It

Estella customer for life!: Originally received an Estella gift box for my baby shower and was blown away by the adorable and unique NYC themed pieces.

Everyone loves these and the nyc red apple

Cullen B.

6. NYC Embroidered Baby Gift Set

Our bestselling baby shower gift: three embroidered organic cotton bodysuits fit for a New Yorker, four hand-knit rattles to match, and an NYC ABCs board book, all arriving in a gift box. It covers the first months beautifully and looks just as good being unwrapped in front of the whole shower.

7. Pig Stuffed Animal (Charlotte)

Charlotte the Pig is all charm, with a bright pink snout and a playful spirit. Hand-knit in Peru with a soft organic cotton exterior, she’s a huggable friend for cuddles and adventures, and a sweet gift for any baby.

8. Knit Doll, Frank Dog

Frank the knit dog doll is a lovable companion for any baby. Hand-knit in Peru with a soft organic cotton exterior, this 12-inch doll is perfect for cuddling. The iconic taxi design on Frank’s chest gives it a unique, city-inspired look. It’s a thoughtful and adorable gift that will quickly become a baby’s best friend. It's a perfect toy for any baby, whether they're two months old or eight months old.

Why Parents Love It

Great dog!: I love this dog. I have bought it for other people's children, and it's always their favorite. I just bought one for my soon-to-be-born grandson.

Patricia R.

Great quality & so cute!!😍

Lisa

9. NYC Little Explorers Baby Gift Set

Six pieces for wearing, playing and reading: two organic cotton bodysuits, each with a different New York print, a matching bib covered in the city’s icons, two hand-knit rattles of a yellow taxi and a Big Apple, and a New York board book. A complete baby shower gift that grows with the baby through the first months.

10. Baby Loves NY Gift Set

Eight of New York’s most iconic things, made for baby: an organic cotton bodysuit with a hot dog and pretzel print, a wood bead pacifier clip, five hand-knit rattles (a hot dog, a pretzel, a yellow taxi, a pigeon and a Big Apple) and an NYC ABCs board book. It all arrives in a gift box, ready to be the most-photographed gift at the shower.

11. Pigeon Stuffed Animal (Pedro)

New York’s most famous bird, made huggable. Pedro has a soft organic cotton exterior, hand-knit in Peru, and a personality every city lover will recognize. A charming, unexpected baby shower gift that quickly becomes a nursery favorite.

12. NYC Apple Newborn Rattle

Bring a touch of the Big Apple to your little one with this vibrant NYC apple rattle. Its bright red color, soft texture, and gentle jingle are sure to captivate babies everywhere. Pair it with other NYC-themed toys for a perfect city-inspired gift set.

Why Parents Love It

Loved this perfect rattle! We love NYC and needed this back home as a sweet reminder

Missy

Nice NYC Baby Items: Items well made, cute and unique

13. Avocado Baby Toy Rattle

Introduce your baby to the nutritious avocado with this playful rattle. Hand-knit with an organic cotton exterior, this award-winning toy from Estella offers a fun way for babies to explore new shapes and sounds.

Why Parents Love It

Absolutely Adorable: Estella baby rattles are so soft, adorable and very well made! They definitely make a Great baby gift! Plus their customer service is exceptional!

C Ciccone

Well made. Extremely satisfied. Thank you.

Kathleen D.

14. Elephant Toy Newborn Rattle

Estella’s Toni the Elephant rattle is a timeless favorite among new parents. Crafted in a soothing grey with a soft rattle sound, this toy is perfectly sized for tiny hands. A small heart stitched on its leg symbolizes support for the endangered Sumatran elephant, making it a thoughtful and meaningful gift.

Why Parents Love It

Great Quality: The rattle I chose are not only adorable, but they are great quality. You can see the craftsmanship in each one. We are soooooo happy with them.

Janeth B.

Happy Shopper: I bought three different rattles from here. It was too hard to pick just one. It was for a baby shower gift. Everyone loved them, cutest rattles they’ve seen. I will definitely shop here again.!

Julie

15. Monkey Baby Toy Rattle

This cheerful monkey rattle, with a soft organic cotton exterior, is a delightful addition to any baby shower gift. With its friendly face, long tail, and engaging sounds, it’s sure to keep babies entertained and smiling.

Why Parents Love It

Monkey rattle so adorable: I can’t wait for my grandson to enjoy this adorable hand crocheted monkey rattle. Estella always makes the cutest items. Surely to become a favorite toy of my grand

Regina C.

Adorable and excellent quality!!

Anonymous

16. Lion, Elephant, Giraffe & Monkey Rattles

Estella's jungle-themed baby gift set is an adorable collection of hand-knit rattles in the shape of a lion, elephant, giraffe, and monkey, each crafted in Peru with a soft organic cotton exterior. Ideal for little ones with a love for animals, this bundle is a charming gift option for newborns.

Why Parents Love It

She loved it!: I sent this to my friend -- a new mama who I haven't been able to see in person yet -- and she said this little lion brought happy tears to her eyes! It's a great choice if the babe is ready to be introduced to a rattle.

Anonymous

17. Pierre Dog Organic Knit Dog

Meet Pierre the Dog, a stylish knit doll embodying French chic with his red beret and “Je T’aime” sweater. Standing 12 inches tall, Pierre is ready to become a baby’s new best friend. This doll is a sophisticated choice for a baby shower gift or a sweet present for anyone who adores Parisian flair.

Why Parents Love It

Organic knit doll, Pierre Dog: My 16mth old grandson LOVES Pierre! The toy is very well made, beautiful colors and great size. Don’t hesitate to purchase!!

Marsha B

So chic!: Can’t resist a dog in a sweater. Love this stuffed animal!

Kelley

18. Whale Luxury Baby Gift Set

For a baby shower gift with a seaside spirit, this luxury set pairs a whale romper with a matching hat, a whale lovey and two rattles. It’s a complete, coordinated gift that’s as lovely to unwrap as it is to use. See more of our luxury baby gifts.

19. NYC Swaddle Baby Gift Set

Everything for the first cuddles and first stories: an NYC print swaddle, an NYC ABCs board book and two hand-knit rattles. A sweet, practical baby shower gift that every new parent will use from day one.

20. NYC All Over Organic Baby Bib

This stylish organic baby bib is a must-have for fans of the Big City. Featuring a fun mix of iconic NYC images—taxis, pretzels, bridges, and more—this reversible cotton bib adds a playful touch to any outfit while keeping your little one clean.

Why Parents Love It

Great Gift: Love the Big City Bib. Great design and the fabric is very soft. I've been purchasing gifts from Estella for many years now and the experience is always exceptional. All my friends and family who have received gifts from Estella absolutely love them and I've enjoyed lots of pictures and videos of little ones in Estella onesies and bibs. The toy rattles are also a big hit.

Anonymous

21. NYC ABCs Baby Gift Set

Learn the ABCs, the NYC way. This simple, statement baby shower gift pairs an NYC ABCs board book with two hand-knit rattles of New York icons: a yellow taxi and a Big Apple. No sizes to guess, and it’s ready to read from the very first bedtime story.

22. Hand Knit Baby Bonnet Hat

A hand-knit baby bonnet is the kind of classic piece new parents reach for again and again. Soft, sweet and timeless, it keeps little heads cozy on walks and looks just as lovely in newborn photos. A small, thoughtful addition to any baby shower gift.

Why Parents Love It

Baby hat: My future granddaughter will look very cute in her well made, warm hat! and glad that I could support a small business.( P.S. I am a native New Yorker) Thank you :-)

Anonymous

Our favorite hats!: So well made, soft, and such a great fit for tiny heads. I love that they have a classic look and arent too chunky.

Jackie G.

23. NYC Romper & Rattle Baby Gift Set

New York, all over. An organic cotton romper covered in the city’s most notable icons, paired with your choice of hand-knit rattle: taxi, apple, pretzel or hot dog. A truly unique baby shower gift every New York lover is sure to adore.

24. Whale Long Knit Baby Romper

For babies born in the summer or who love the water, a cozy knit romper featuring cheerful whale prints and classic stripes is ideal. Made from organic cotton, it offers comfort and style for both everyday wear and special occasions.

Why Parents Love It

Adorable!: The whale romper is simply a,dorable! Well made and oh so soft. I’m so happy with this purchase.

Anonymous

Loved it!: Thank you. Great quality and very timely delivery!

Adrienne

Love how soft the fabric is

Danielle

25. Octopus Security Blanket

Estella’s octopus security baby blanket is a perfect comfort for cuddles, travel, or adding a whimsical touch to the nursery. Crafted from high-quality organic cotton, it features a friendly octopus face and a fun, tactile pattern. Reinforced hems enhance durability, ensuring it remains a reliable companion for your little one.

Why Parents Love It

Adorable: The Octopus lovey is going to be hard to give up to my new grandson! It’s wonderfully soft & well made. I appreciate your products.

Diane P.

Beautiful products: This item, and others I have purchased, have all been gifts for those I work with. They are such beautifully made products and have been so appreciated. Thanks so much for your wonderful store.

Anonymous

26. NYC Taxi Lovey Security Blanket

A hand-knit taxi lovey with pom-pom wheels, about 14" x 14", just the right size for cuddling and carrying around. A sweet first comfort object for the newest New Yorker, and an easy one to tuck into a diaper bag.

Why Parents Love It

Great gift for a friend who loves NYC: Beautifully made! Made a great gift for a friend whose favorite city is NYC.

Baby gift was a hit!: I purchased the organic baby lovey blanket and rattle with taxi theme as a baby gift for a very special friend and she loved it.

27. Welcome NYC Baby Gift Basket

Six NYC pieces presented in a handwoven rattan caddy that becomes the nursery’s diaper station. The basket is the presentation, so there’s nothing to wrap: just bring it to the shower and watch it get passed around the room.

28. Frank NYC Baby Gift Basket

Our showstopper: twelve pieces in a handwoven rattan caddy, from swaddle to first birthday. Three organic cotton bodysuits in a range of sizes, Frank the knit dog doll, an NYC swaddle, four hand-knit rattles, a reversible NYC bib and an NYC ABCs board book, all lovingly packed into a basket that stays in the nursery for years. Explore all of our baby gift baskets.

More Baby Shower Gift Ideas

Still deciding? See our full edit of baby shower gifts, organized by budget, or browse unique baby gifts and luxury baby gifts. Every order includes a gift receipt with no prices, and gift boxing is complimentary on orders over $175.