A newborn at Christmas is the best present of all, and choosing a gift for one is a sweet way to welcome the newest member of the family. Newborns don’t need much: something soft for first cuddles, something lovely to look at, and clothes they can grow into. The parents, on the other hand, will treasure a gift that’s beautiful, useful and made to last. The best newborn Christmas gifts do both, and the very best become the keepsakes the family pulls out every December.
Shop this story
Gifts from this story
2 colors available
Every gift in this guide is from Estella, a family-owned New York brand making baby gifts since 2003. Our toys are hand-knit one at a time by artisans in Peru with a soft organic cotton exterior, and our clothing is organic cotton. We’ve earned 1,800+ five-star reviews from 55,000+ families, been featured in Vogue, and you’ll never find us on Amazon.
In this guide:
- Our quick picks
- Best baby Christmas gifts for a newborn
- Gifts for first cuddles
- Newborn gift sets
- Luxury newborn Christmas gifts
- 7 tips for choosing a newborn gift
- Frequently asked questions
Our Quick Picks
- Best overall: the NYC Embroidered Baby Gift Set ($228), our bestseller, arriving gift-boxed.
- Best under $50: the NYC Bib & Rattle Baby Gift Set ($46), a sweet first gift.
- Best keepsake: Frank the Dog ($72), waiting in the nursery for years to come.
- The showstopper: the Heirloom NYC Baby Gift Basket ($695), seventeen pieces from newborn to 18 months.
Best Baby Christmas Gifts for a Newborn
NYC Embroidered Baby Gift Set
Three embroidered organic cotton bodysuits, four hand-knit rattles and an NYC ABCs board book, all in a gift box. It covers the first months beautifully: something to wear, something to hold and something to read.
Premium Feel: The fabric feels luxurious and the rattle quickly became a favorite toy.
Frank the Dog
Our most iconic piece: a 12-inch hand-knit dog with floppy ears, a stitched face and a little taxi on his chest. A newborn will gaze at him; a toddler will carry him everywhere.
Great dog! I love this dog. I have bought it for other people's children, and it's always their favorite.
Snowman Baby Rattle
A cheerful hand-knit snowman with a cozy hat and a carrot nose: a first-Christmas keepsake that comes out every winter.
Gnome Baby Rattle
A friendly hand-knit gnome, full of holiday whimsy. Tie it to the ribbon of a bigger gift, or tuck it into a stocking.
Loved it: My friend was so happy to receive this for a gift it shipped quickly and is excellent quality. Thank you!
I Love Taxi NYC Baby Rattle
Our classic yellow taxi rattle with a red heart: light, soft and easy for tiny hands once they start to grasp.
Gifts for First Cuddles
Whale Baby Gift Set
A whale lovey, a hand-knit whale rattle and a striped knit hat: three cozy pieces in one gift, with no tricky sizes to guess.
Love this!: Purchased this as a gift, and the new parents were so pleased. So glad I came across this!!
NYC Taxi Lovey Security Blanket
A hand-knit taxi lovey with pom-pom wheels, about 14" x 14": small enough for little hands, and often the first comfort object a baby loves.
Great gift for a friend who loves NYC: Beautifully made! Made a great gift for a friend whose favorite city is NYC.
NYC Print Baby Swaddle Blanket
A breathable muslin swaddle printed with New York’s landmarks and favorite foods, from the Statue of Liberty to the hot dog. New parents use a swaddle every single day.
Beautiful swaddle: This is my second purchase of these soft and beautiful swaddles.
Striped Knit Baby Hat
A soft organic cotton knit hat in classic stripes, to keep little heads cozy on winter walks. A sweet $18 add-on to any gift.
Newborn Gift Sets
NYC Bib & Rattle Baby Gift Set
An NYC print bib with a hand-knit rattle: a simple, sweet first gift at $46.
NYC Swaddle Baby Gift Set
An NYC print swaddle, the NYC ABCs board book and two hand-knit rattles: everything for first cuddles and first stories.
Best for NY Babies! Our friends love the NYC themed gifts. It's fun for the baby and gets a good smile from the parents :) Really cute!
Urban Tot NYC Baby Gift Set
An NYC print organic cotton bodysuit and matching bib with three hand-knit rattles: a taxi, a hot dog and a pretzel.
Welcome NYC Baby Gift Basket
Six pieces in a handwoven rattan caddy: an organic cotton NYC print bodysuit, hand-knit taxi and hot dog rattles, a bandana bib and the NYC ABCs board book. Once it’s unpacked, the caddy becomes the nursery’s diaper station.
Luxury Newborn Christmas Gifts
Ultimate NYC Baby Gift Set
Frank the Dog, five hand-knit rattles, an NYC print swaddle, My First Book of New York and a pacifier clip, arriving in a gift box. No sizes to guess.
Frank NYC Baby Gift Basket
Twelve pieces built around Frank the Dog in a handwoven rattan caddy, from the first weeks to the first birthday.
The only place I buy baby gifts: Every time a friend has a kid, they get one of the beautiful Estella NYC gift sets. EVERY time they call me and tell me how amazing it is.
Heirloom NYC Baby Gift Basket
Our most complete gift: seventeen pieces in a handwoven caddy, with organic cotton clothes from newborn to 18 months, Frank the Dog, a large taxi plush, a taxi lovey and five hand-knit rattles. See all of our baby gift baskets.
7 Tips for Choosing the Perfect Gift for a Newborn
1. Size up. Newborns outgrow 0–3 months in weeks. Choose 3–6 months, or a gift with no size at all.
2. Think about the parents. A swaddle, a bib or a basket that organizes the nursery is a gift they’ll use every day.
3. Give one thing to keep. A hand-knit doll or rattle often becomes the toy the family saves.
4. Go gender-neutral if you’re not sure. Most of our gifts are made for any baby.
5. Choose a theme that means something. A city the family loves, a favorite animal or a sport makes a gift personal.
6. Keep it simple. One beautiful gift often means more than a pile of things.
7. Make it ready to give. Add a gift message and gift box so it arrives looking its best.
What Size to Give a Newborn
Choose 3–6 months for a newborn so the outfit lasts through the winter, or 6–12 months for a baby born in the fall. Rattles, loveys, swaddles and books need no size at all.
Ready to Give for Christmas
Add a free gift message in your cart, and every order includes a gift receipt with no prices. Gift boxing is $8, complimentary on orders over $175. Orders ship within 1–2 business days, with free shipping on U.S. orders over $75; order early, since carriers slow down in December.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I buy my newborn Christmas gifts?
A newborn won’t remember their first Christmas, but the family will. One meaningful keepsake, like a hand-knit doll or a holiday rattle, is a lovely way to mark it.
Are newborn Christmas gifts for the baby or the parents?
Both. The best gifts are useful for the parents now, like a swaddle or a gift set with clothes, and become the baby’s keepsakes later.
What is a good Christmas gift for a newborn?
A soft rattle or doll, a swaddle, and an outfit in 3–6 months, or a gift set that combines them in one box.
What are Estella toys made of?
Our knit toys have an organic cotton exterior, hand-knit by artisans in Peru, with a soft polyester fill. Each product page lists its materials.
Can I buy Estella on Amazon?
No. Estella is sold only at estella-nyc.com and at select museum and boutique partners.
More Christmas Gift Ideas, Made with Love
See all of our Baby’s First Christmas gifts, our newborn baby gifts and our luxury baby gifts.
Keep reading:
Leave a comment
This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.